Exact request sent to the run panel.
{
"source": "retrieve",
"template": {
"id": "producthunt_launch_review",
"slug": "ph-launch-roast",
"name": "Product Hunt Launch Roast",
"categoryId": "STARTUP_TECH"
},
"inputs": {
"target": "",
"normalizedTarget": {
"raw": ""
}
},
"agentHint": "You are conducting a Product Hunt launch review with deep visual analysis. Adapt to the UI.\n\n**TASK CONFIGURATION:**\n- Target: \n\n---\n\n## STEP 1: NAVIGATE TO PRODUCT PAGE\n\n1. If is a full URL, go directly to it\n2. If is a product name, search on producthunt.com\n3. Navigate to the product page\n4. Wait for full page load including media\n5. **Verify access:**\n - Product exists? Proceed\n - Product removed/unavailable? Report error\n\n---\n\n## STEP 2: EXTRACT PRODUCT METADATA\n\n### Basic Info\n- Product name\n- Tagline\n- Full description\n- Maker(s) / team\n- Launch date\n- Category/topics\n- Website URL\n\n### Engagement Metrics\n- Upvote count\n- Comment count\n- Ranking (if visible - #1 Product of the Day, etc.)\n- Review count and average rating\n\n---\n\n## STEP 3: EXTRACT ALL VISUAL ASSETS\n\n**Capture URLs and analyze each visual element:**\n\n### Logo/Icon\n- Logo image URL\n- Note: This is the primary brand identifier\n\n### Gallery Images\n- All image URLs in the gallery\n- Note the order (first image is most important)\n- Count total images\n\n### Demo Video (if present)\n- Video thumbnail URL\n- Video presence (yes/no)\n- Video platform (YouTube, Vimeo, native)\n\n### Maker Avatars\n- Maker profile pictures (team representation)\n\n---\n\n## STEP 4: ANALYZE LOGO/ICON (CRITICAL)\n\n**Describe and evaluate the product logo:**\n\n### Visual Description\n- **Shape**: What shape is the icon? (Square, rounded, abstract, letterform)\n- **Colors**: What colors are used? Color count?\n- **Style**: Flat, gradient, 3D, minimal, detailed?\n- **Symbolism**: What does the icon represent? Obvious or abstract?\n- **Text**: Any text in the logo? Readable at small sizes?\n\n### Quality Assessment\n- **Clarity**: Is it clear at small sizes (favicon-sized)?\n- **Memorability**: Would you recognize it again?\n- **Professionalism**: Does it look like a real product or a side project?\n- **Category fit**: Does it match the product category expectations?\n- **Uniqueness**: Generic or distinctive?\n\n### Logo Score: /10\n- Consider: clarity, professionalism, memorability, category fit\n\n---\n\n## STEP 5: ANALYZE GALLERY IMAGES (CRITICAL)\n\n**For each image in the gallery, analyze in detail:**\n\n### Image 1 (Hero Image - Most Important)\n- **What it shows**: Main UI? Feature? Value prop visualization?\n- **Device frame**: Browser mockup? Phone? Desktop? None?\n- **UI quality**: Does the product look polished?\n- **Text/annotations**: Any explanatory text overlaid?\n- **Call-out elements**: Arrows, highlights, feature callouts?\n- **Colors/branding**: Consistent with logo? Professional palette?\n- **Clarity**: Can you understand what the product does from this image?\n\n### Images 2-N (Additional Gallery Images)\nFor each additional image:\n- What feature/aspect does this show?\n- Does it add new information or feel repetitive?\n- Visual quality consistency with first image\n- Storytelling progression (do images build a narrative?)\n\n### Gallery Overall Assessment\n- **Total images**: Count\n- **Variety**: Different features shown or repetitive?\n- **Quality consistency**: All same level of polish?\n- **Story told**: Do the images together explain the product?\n- **Device frames**: Consistent framing approach?\n- **Annotations**: Helpful or cluttered?\n\n### Gallery Score: /10\n- Consider: first impression, storytelling, quality, variety\n\n---\n\n## STEP 6: ANALYZE DEMO VIDEO (if present)\n\n### Video Thumbnail\n- **What's shown**: Product UI? Person? Text?\n- **Play button appeal**: Does it make you want to click?\n- **Quality**: Professional or amateur looking?\n- **Text on thumbnail**: Title, hook, or clean?\n\n### Video Presence Value\n- Having a video vs. not having one\n- Thumbnail effectiveness as a \"click trigger\"\n\n### Video Score: /10 (or N/A if no video)\n\n---\n\n## STEP 7: ANALYZE TAGLINE & DESCRIPTION\n\n### Tagline Assessment\n- **Clarity**: Do I know what this does immediately?\n- **Benefit focus**: Features vs. outcomes?\n- **Length**: Optimal or too long/short?\n- **Uniqueness**: Generic or memorable?\n- **Buzzword check**: \"AI-powered\", \"Revolutionary\", etc.\n\n### Description Assessment\n- **Opening hook**: Does the first line grab attention?\n- **Value proposition**: Clear problem → solution?\n- **Feature explanation**: Clear and compelling?\n- **Social proof**: Any credibility indicators?\n- **CTA**: What action does it encourage?\n\n### Copy Score: /10\n\n---\n\n## STEP 8: VISUAL + COPY ALIGNMENT\n\n**How well do visuals and words work together?**\n\n- Does the tagline match what images show?\n- Do images prove the claims in description?\n- Is there a cohesive brand feeling?\n- Any disconnects between promise and visuals?\n\n### Alignment Score: /10\n\n---\n\n## STEP 9: ANALYZE COMMENTS & MAKER ENGAGEMENT\n\n### Comment Sentiment\n- Scroll through comments\n- Positive vs. negative vs. questions ratio\n- Common themes in feedback\n- Concerns raised\n\n### Maker Responses\n- Are makers responding to comments?\n- Response quality and tone\n- Addressing concerns or defensive?\n- Response speed indicators\n\n### Community Engagement Score: /10\n\n---\n\n## STEP 10: GENERATE LAUNCH ROAST\n\n### 1. FIRST IMPRESSION SCORE (0-100)\nCombined assessment of:\n- Logo impact\n- Hero image\n- Tagline clarity\n- Overall \"would I click\" factor\n\n### 2. LOGO ROAST\n- What works\n- What doesn't\n- Specific improvement suggestions\n\n### 3. IMAGE GALLERY TEARDOWN\n- Hero image critique\n- Gallery storytelling assessment\n- Specific images that hurt or help\n- What's missing from the gallery\n\n### 4. VIDEO ASSESSMENT\n- Thumbnail effectiveness\n- Value of having/not having video\n- Suggestions\n\n### 5. TAGLINE TEARDOWN\n- What it's trying to say\n- What it actually communicates\n- Rewrite suggestions\n\n### 6. DESCRIPTION CRITIQUE\n- Opening effectiveness\n- Value prop clarity\n- What to cut, what to add\n\n### 7. THE HONEST REVIEW\n- Would this product get your upvote?\n- Target audience clarity\n- Market positioning assessment\n- What would make YOU try it?\n\n### 8. VISUAL LAUNCH PLAYBOOK\n5 specific visual improvements:\n1. Logo/icon fix\n2. Hero image improvement\n3. Gallery enhancement\n4. Video recommendation\n5. Overall visual branding suggestion\n\n### 9. COPY FIXES\n3 specific text improvements:\n1. Tagline rewrite\n2. Description opening fix\n3. Feature explanation improvement\n\n---\n\n## STEP 11: REPORT RESULTS\n\n```json\n{\n \"product\": {\n \"name\": \"\",\n \"tagline\": \"\",\n \"description\": \"\",\n \"website\": \"\",\n \"launchDate\": \"\",\n \"makers\": [],\n \"categories\": []\n },\n \"engagement\": {\n \"upvotes\": <number>,\n \"comments\": <number>,\n \"ranking\": \"\",\n \"reviews\": { \"count\": 0, \"average\": 0 }\n },\n \"visualAssets\": {\n \"logoUrl\": \"\",\n \"logoAnalysis\": {\n \"description\": \"\",\n \"colors\": [],\n \"style\": \"\",\n \"clarity\": \"\",\n \"memorability\": \"\",\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"gallery\": {\n \"totalImages\": <number>,\n \"imageAnalysis\": [\n {\n \"position\": 1,\n \"url\": \"\",\n \"description\": \"\",\n \"showsFeature\": \"\",\n \"deviceFrame\": \"\",\n \"hasAnnotations\": false,\n \"quality\": \"\",\n \"effectiveness\": \"\"\n }\n ],\n \"storytellingAssessment\": \"\",\n \"varietyScore\": \"\",\n \"overallScore\": <0-10>\n },\n \"video\": {\n \"present\": true|false,\n \"thumbnailUrl\": \"\",\n \"thumbnailAnalysis\": \"\",\n \"score\": <0-10 or null>\n }\n },\n \"copyAnalysis\": {\n \"tagline\": {\n \"text\": \"\",\n \"clarity\": \"\",\n \"effectiveness\": \"\",\n \"buzzwordCount\": <number>,\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"description\": {\n \"openingHook\": \"\",\n \"valueProposition\": \"\",\n \"score\": <0-10>\n }\n },\n \"visualCopyAlignment\": {\n \"assessment\": \"\",\n \"disconnects\": [],\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"communityEngagement\": {\n \"commentSentiment\": \"\",\n \"makerResponsiveness\": \"\",\n \"commonConcerns\": [],\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"overallScores\": {\n \"firstImpression\": <0-100>,\n \"logo\": <0-10>,\n \"gallery\": <0-10>,\n \"video\": <0-10 or null>,\n \"copy\": <0-10>,\n \"alignment\": <0-10>,\n \"community\": <0-10>\n },\n \"roast\": {\n \"logoRoast\": \"\",\n \"galleryTeardown\": \"\",\n \"taglineTeardown\": \"\",\n \"descriptionCritique\": \"\",\n \"honestReview\": \"\",\n \"wouldUpvote\": true|false,\n \"whyOrWhyNot\": \"\"\n },\n \"improvements\": {\n \"visualFixes\": [],\n \"copyFixes\": [],\n \"priorityOrder\": []\n }\n}\n```\n\n---\n\n## PRODUCT HUNT VISUAL BEST PRACTICES (Reference)\n\n**What works on PH:**\n- Clean, readable images at small sizes\n- Device frames that match target platform\n- Annotations that explain without cluttering\n- Video that shows the product in action\n- Logo that's recognizable at 64x64px\n- Gallery that tells a story (problem → solution → features → social proof)\n\n**Common visual mistakes:**\n- Images too busy/small to read\n- No device frames (looks unprofessional)\n- All images show same thing\n- No video (losing engagement)\n- Logo that's illegible when small\n- Inconsistent visual branding across assets",
"userInput": "You are conducting a Product Hunt launch review with deep visual analysis. Adapt to the UI.\n\n**TASK CONFIGURATION:**\n- Target: \n\n---\n\n## STEP 1: NAVIGATE TO PRODUCT PAGE\n\n1. If is a full URL, go directly to it\n2. If is a product name, search on producthunt.com\n3. Navigate to the product page\n4. Wait for full page load including media\n5. **Verify access:**\n - Product exists? Proceed\n - Product removed/unavailable? Report error\n\n---\n\n## STEP 2: EXTRACT PRODUCT METADATA\n\n### Basic Info\n- Product name\n- Tagline\n- Full description\n- Maker(s) / team\n- Launch date\n- Category/topics\n- Website URL\n\n### Engagement Metrics\n- Upvote count\n- Comment count\n- Ranking (if visible - #1 Product of the Day, etc.)\n- Review count and average rating\n\n---\n\n## STEP 3: EXTRACT ALL VISUAL ASSETS\n\n**Capture URLs and analyze each visual element:**\n\n### Logo/Icon\n- Logo image URL\n- Note: This is the primary brand identifier\n\n### Gallery Images\n- All image URLs in the gallery\n- Note the order (first image is most important)\n- Count total images\n\n### Demo Video (if present)\n- Video thumbnail URL\n- Video presence (yes/no)\n- Video platform (YouTube, Vimeo, native)\n\n### Maker Avatars\n- Maker profile pictures (team representation)\n\n---\n\n## STEP 4: ANALYZE LOGO/ICON (CRITICAL)\n\n**Describe and evaluate the product logo:**\n\n### Visual Description\n- **Shape**: What shape is the icon? (Square, rounded, abstract, letterform)\n- **Colors**: What colors are used? Color count?\n- **Style**: Flat, gradient, 3D, minimal, detailed?\n- **Symbolism**: What does the icon represent? Obvious or abstract?\n- **Text**: Any text in the logo? Readable at small sizes?\n\n### Quality Assessment\n- **Clarity**: Is it clear at small sizes (favicon-sized)?\n- **Memorability**: Would you recognize it again?\n- **Professionalism**: Does it look like a real product or a side project?\n- **Category fit**: Does it match the product category expectations?\n- **Uniqueness**: Generic or distinctive?\n\n### Logo Score: /10\n- Consider: clarity, professionalism, memorability, category fit\n\n---\n\n## STEP 5: ANALYZE GALLERY IMAGES (CRITICAL)\n\n**For each image in the gallery, analyze in detail:**\n\n### Image 1 (Hero Image - Most Important)\n- **What it shows**: Main UI? Feature? Value prop visualization?\n- **Device frame**: Browser mockup? Phone? Desktop? None?\n- **UI quality**: Does the product look polished?\n- **Text/annotations**: Any explanatory text overlaid?\n- **Call-out elements**: Arrows, highlights, feature callouts?\n- **Colors/branding**: Consistent with logo? Professional palette?\n- **Clarity**: Can you understand what the product does from this image?\n\n### Images 2-N (Additional Gallery Images)\nFor each additional image:\n- What feature/aspect does this show?\n- Does it add new information or feel repetitive?\n- Visual quality consistency with first image\n- Storytelling progression (do images build a narrative?)\n\n### Gallery Overall Assessment\n- **Total images**: Count\n- **Variety**: Different features shown or repetitive?\n- **Quality consistency**: All same level of polish?\n- **Story told**: Do the images together explain the product?\n- **Device frames**: Consistent framing approach?\n- **Annotations**: Helpful or cluttered?\n\n### Gallery Score: /10\n- Consider: first impression, storytelling, quality, variety\n\n---\n\n## STEP 6: ANALYZE DEMO VIDEO (if present)\n\n### Video Thumbnail\n- **What's shown**: Product UI? Person? Text?\n- **Play button appeal**: Does it make you want to click?\n- **Quality**: Professional or amateur looking?\n- **Text on thumbnail**: Title, hook, or clean?\n\n### Video Presence Value\n- Having a video vs. not having one\n- Thumbnail effectiveness as a \"click trigger\"\n\n### Video Score: /10 (or N/A if no video)\n\n---\n\n## STEP 7: ANALYZE TAGLINE & DESCRIPTION\n\n### Tagline Assessment\n- **Clarity**: Do I know what this does immediately?\n- **Benefit focus**: Features vs. outcomes?\n- **Length**: Optimal or too long/short?\n- **Uniqueness**: Generic or memorable?\n- **Buzzword check**: \"AI-powered\", \"Revolutionary\", etc.\n\n### Description Assessment\n- **Opening hook**: Does the first line grab attention?\n- **Value proposition**: Clear problem → solution?\n- **Feature explanation**: Clear and compelling?\n- **Social proof**: Any credibility indicators?\n- **CTA**: What action does it encourage?\n\n### Copy Score: /10\n\n---\n\n## STEP 8: VISUAL + COPY ALIGNMENT\n\n**How well do visuals and words work together?**\n\n- Does the tagline match what images show?\n- Do images prove the claims in description?\n- Is there a cohesive brand feeling?\n- Any disconnects between promise and visuals?\n\n### Alignment Score: /10\n\n---\n\n## STEP 9: ANALYZE COMMENTS & MAKER ENGAGEMENT\n\n### Comment Sentiment\n- Scroll through comments\n- Positive vs. negative vs. questions ratio\n- Common themes in feedback\n- Concerns raised\n\n### Maker Responses\n- Are makers responding to comments?\n- Response quality and tone\n- Addressing concerns or defensive?\n- Response speed indicators\n\n### Community Engagement Score: /10\n\n---\n\n## STEP 10: GENERATE LAUNCH ROAST\n\n### 1. FIRST IMPRESSION SCORE (0-100)\nCombined assessment of:\n- Logo impact\n- Hero image\n- Tagline clarity\n- Overall \"would I click\" factor\n\n### 2. LOGO ROAST\n- What works\n- What doesn't\n- Specific improvement suggestions\n\n### 3. IMAGE GALLERY TEARDOWN\n- Hero image critique\n- Gallery storytelling assessment\n- Specific images that hurt or help\n- What's missing from the gallery\n\n### 4. VIDEO ASSESSMENT\n- Thumbnail effectiveness\n- Value of having/not having video\n- Suggestions\n\n### 5. TAGLINE TEARDOWN\n- What it's trying to say\n- What it actually communicates\n- Rewrite suggestions\n\n### 6. DESCRIPTION CRITIQUE\n- Opening effectiveness\n- Value prop clarity\n- What to cut, what to add\n\n### 7. THE HONEST REVIEW\n- Would this product get your upvote?\n- Target audience clarity\n- Market positioning assessment\n- What would make YOU try it?\n\n### 8. VISUAL LAUNCH PLAYBOOK\n5 specific visual improvements:\n1. Logo/icon fix\n2. Hero image improvement\n3. Gallery enhancement\n4. Video recommendation\n5. Overall visual branding suggestion\n\n### 9. COPY FIXES\n3 specific text improvements:\n1. Tagline rewrite\n2. Description opening fix\n3. Feature explanation improvement\n\n---\n\n## STEP 11: REPORT RESULTS\n\n```json\n{\n \"product\": {\n \"name\": \"\",\n \"tagline\": \"\",\n \"description\": \"\",\n \"website\": \"\",\n \"launchDate\": \"\",\n \"makers\": [],\n \"categories\": []\n },\n \"engagement\": {\n \"upvotes\": <number>,\n \"comments\": <number>,\n \"ranking\": \"\",\n \"reviews\": { \"count\": 0, \"average\": 0 }\n },\n \"visualAssets\": {\n \"logoUrl\": \"\",\n \"logoAnalysis\": {\n \"description\": \"\",\n \"colors\": [],\n \"style\": \"\",\n \"clarity\": \"\",\n \"memorability\": \"\",\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"gallery\": {\n \"totalImages\": <number>,\n \"imageAnalysis\": [\n {\n \"position\": 1,\n \"url\": \"\",\n \"description\": \"\",\n \"showsFeature\": \"\",\n \"deviceFrame\": \"\",\n \"hasAnnotations\": false,\n \"quality\": \"\",\n \"effectiveness\": \"\"\n }\n ],\n \"storytellingAssessment\": \"\",\n \"varietyScore\": \"\",\n \"overallScore\": <0-10>\n },\n \"video\": {\n \"present\": true|false,\n \"thumbnailUrl\": \"\",\n \"thumbnailAnalysis\": \"\",\n \"score\": <0-10 or null>\n }\n },\n \"copyAnalysis\": {\n \"tagline\": {\n \"text\": \"\",\n \"clarity\": \"\",\n \"effectiveness\": \"\",\n \"buzzwordCount\": <number>,\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"description\": {\n \"openingHook\": \"\",\n \"valueProposition\": \"\",\n \"score\": <0-10>\n }\n },\n \"visualCopyAlignment\": {\n \"assessment\": \"\",\n \"disconnects\": [],\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"communityEngagement\": {\n \"commentSentiment\": \"\",\n \"makerResponsiveness\": \"\",\n \"commonConcerns\": [],\n \"score\": <0-10>\n },\n \"overallScores\": {\n \"firstImpression\": <0-100>,\n \"logo\": <0-10>,\n \"gallery\": <0-10>,\n \"video\": <0-10 or null>,\n \"copy\": <0-10>,\n \"alignment\": <0-10>,\n \"community\": <0-10>\n },\n \"roast\": {\n \"logoRoast\": \"\",\n \"galleryTeardown\": \"\",\n \"taglineTeardown\": \"\",\n \"descriptionCritique\": \"\",\n \"honestReview\": \"\",\n \"wouldUpvote\": true|false,\n \"whyOrWhyNot\": \"\"\n },\n \"improvements\": {\n \"visualFixes\": [],\n \"copyFixes\": [],\n \"priorityOrder\": []\n }\n}\n```\n\n---\n\n## PRODUCT HUNT VISUAL BEST PRACTICES (Reference)\n\n**What works on PH:**\n- Clean, readable images at small sizes\n- Device frames that match target platform\n- Annotations that explain without cluttering\n- Video that shows the product in action\n- Logo that's recognizable at 64x64px\n- Gallery that tells a story (problem → solution → features → social proof)\n\n**Common visual mistakes:**\n- Images too busy/small to read\n- No device frames (looks unprofessional)\n- All images show same thing\n- No video (losing engagement)\n- Logo that's illegible when small\n- Inconsistent visual branding across assets",
"urls": [],
"meta": {
"createdAt": "",
"userAgent": ""
}
}
Add to Chrome